Reviews, Reviews, Reviews

The Edmonton Journal asked its younger readers to submit their reviews of Order of the Phoenix; they received nearly 200. Here are the winners (who shared almost $1000 in prize money), excerpts from their reviews, and judge commentary.
A few of this editor's favorites:

I didn't like the transition from the laid-back Harry to the uptight, yelling Harry. I already have enough of that from my sister. -- Stephanie Bradshaw, 11

When you're on a date, do not mention that you are going to meet another girl right after the date. -- Bradley Cox, 12

Being a teenager is no excuse for being rude. -- Fiona Swann, 11