Well best of luck to them but personally now I think is the time to just give up

Not this issue again…
I honestly think there is no point in RDR trying again.

you’re. joking. give. it. up.
geessshhh!

on a different note: Thank you leaky for making the comments go up faster!

for a second i thought you said the judge was Robert Pattinson. i was like WTF ? but its patterson , heh.

It is time for them to give up, they couldn’t win the case the first time and they won’t win it this time.

RDR needs to give it up.

And here we go again . . .

I don’t understand what RDR hopes to gain at this point unless they are seeking damages for lost sales (which they won’t win.)

not much fun for either side, that case. wish they wouldn’t file appeal. they’ll lose! i wonder what SVA thinks of it…

A minor nit, they actually filed a notice of appeal, the actual appeal comes later.

Oh please. Give me a break. Do we need to spell iy out for them
:N-O C-H-A-N-C-E

RDR could win on appeal if they can point to a legal flaw in the judge’s reasoning which means they should have won the court case. It might also be a bargaining ploy and to allow more negotiating time if discussions are still going on. I don’t think there is any obligation on them to submit the appeal they have now given notice of.

argh, take a hint, please!!
give up :\
.. im sure this is just wasting their money ..

RDR is appealing because they are being represented by a organization which has vocally made its goal clear of taking rights away from authors. that is what the Stanford fair use projects goal is. they belive it is wrong for a author to own their creation, and that fair use needs to be expanded to allow people like RDR books to profit off exploting the hard work of others.

OH. MY. GOSH.

YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME.

facepalm

Why waste your and jkrs money and time on this… you wont win…