Advertisement

deathly hallows should not be split. IM WITH THE PERSON THAT SAYD A FOUR HOUR HARRY POTTER FILM WOULD BE A TREAT!!! that would be awesome…

@NO2YATES- just because we dont agree with you that OOTP was the worst doesnt mean we are delusional. We just like to look at this realistically- kind of like the new cast members who also get butchered every time we hear of a new one. I think based on what I know of how the world works we all need to remember ,including myself that we all percieve these films differently and we never have say so- besides if you are a true HP fan you will love the movie anyway. I have never seen any changes to the movies that have totally ruined the book to the point where they should be condemed all bad.

Bleh, I’m not happy about this, but can’t really say I’m surprised, 7 will be a though nut to direct, so no wonder no one else is exactly eager to step in.

Idunno..at first I though OOTP was the best flm of alll time, but it gets old after watching it a couple of times and I start to miss some things they had cut out… te performances are the best yet, but I wished he had put more flow into the movie. Well, I can’t say that I don’t want him on the last one, cuz he might do a better job on HBP, bt i’m not sure. The only HP film I had personally fell deeply in love with was prizoner of azkaban, cuz it had unexpected touches in it, so I wasn’t like “oh yea I know exactly what happens the next second…yawn“

Like most Leaky fans, I am much more a fan of the books than of the films. But other than GOF, I enjoyed watching the films. I particularly liked POA and OOTP and would be happy if David Yates finishes the series.

that’s exactly how i felt too, weseley person and that’s why they should bring cuaron back. When i watched OOTP, i knew actually what was happening next and it made it kind of boring verus when i watch POA, it was more of a different experience from the book. I too loved prisoner of azkaban, i’m just so disappointed that other people don’t like it as well so Warner Brother wouldn’t risk bring him back. Hopefully, i might be wrong on that.

They are saving hundreds of kids at my school grief. My English teacher has this thing with showing movie adaptions of books with our novel studies, and guess what book she has us do? ...

Actually, meek, you’d be surprised as to the number of people who consider Azkaban the best in the series, there are quite a lot of us. Critics have loved it too, I think it still remains the most critically acclaimed HP film today. So you shouldn’t be too disappointed, but take pride in your good taste. :)

NOOOO!!! I know alot people like his work and so do I but I think it would bring the whole series together if Columbus came back for the seventh one. Starting with his version and ideas of the story then to tie EVERYTHING up in the same fashion would be amazing. Does anyone agree with me.

Agreed with Saffron. Now where’s that petetion? CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!! CUARON FOR DH!!!!!!!

Cuaron for DH! If not Cuaron, then Del Toro. If not Del Toro, then Yates. If not Yates, then Peter Jackson. If not Peter Jackson, then Tim Burton. If not Tim Burton, I have no idea who would direct DH. >.<

YES!! This is the word I was hoping for I really want Yates to stay and keep the last 3 movies one fluid style. He did an excellent job in Order of the Phoenix and Half Blood Prince is his real test but i think he can do it. I don’t mean to be mean, Lowry is an good author but her blog is very boring. I don’t want 2 Deathly Hallows films, then you’ll have one heavily action packed and one slightly slow. Just pack it into a lotr style 3 hour movie, it can be perfectly fitted in that format. I want 7 movies not 8

YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES AND YES AGAIN

although it sort of depends on how good book 6 is… but im sure it will be amazing

I don’t know about this…honestly, I’d like to see another director take on Deathly Hallows just to mix things up. I thought OOTP was one of the better movies so far, but DH can’t be one of the better ones. I WANT IT TO BE THE BEST, and I don’t think Yates can deliver that.

I just want a 4 hour or longer DH movie so we can include everything. If they cut out Molly’s line, I’ll kill David Heyman!!!!! Why can’t JKR write the script? She could do FABULOUS on that! Hey….maybe Jo could direct! Or maybe the guy who directed the JKR documentary could direct DH…... but seriously, I just want a 4 hour long+, Cuaron or Del Toro directed, JKR scripted, perfect blockbuster extravaganzapalooza of a kick-arse movie thing.

I definitely agree about Cuaron—he would be FANTASTIC with DH, there’s no doubt about it. Unfortunately, I’m pretty sure Warner Bros doesn’t think people will come to see a movie that’s four hours long…just goes to show how little they understand Harry Potter fans.

JKR should write the script!!!!!!

we have already heard that Del Toro and Speilberg are out so I think that if anyone does it – it will be Yates, Cuaron or Columbus. And according to this it most likely is Yates which most dont have a complaint from the sound of it. Cuaron had a similar style to Yates so either would be fine. Columbus did the most by the book but he had the two shortest ones we need to remember and Yates had the LONGEST book – people remember that!

BellaSnape is right. But Del Toro deserves a chance.

Yates does a couple of things well. He has a good line in poignance but he doesn’t come anywhere near epic. I’m sure he’d do an excellent job with other material, but DH needs someone who can hit more than one note. Newell showed that he could do it, but he’s taken.

If Yates does DH it will be the same team he brought in – same composer, same inept editor and same dreary FX. The film series will go out with a whimper, not a bang, and unlike the books will be quickly forgotten.

I can’t understand why Heyday Films would aim so low, unless Dave Heyman is so bored by the series that he wants to leave it on autopilot while he pursues other projects. Dave Heyman also seems to think that Yates did a good job, but in fact OoTP was the worst reviewed of the series. Look for a big box office dip when HBP comes out.

And if 2 parts – it’s going to absolutely awful. Harry Potter Goes Camping, followed by Harry Potter Goes Camping Again. With tons of filler by Steve Kloves. Coming to a mostly empty theater near you.