Isnt it a liitle odd that OOTP, the longest HP book, was the shortest movie??? actually no it’s not a little odd it’s ridiculous!! The movie was destined to suck being that short… it was so chopped up and messy it just didn’t make any logical sense!!! The only reason why millions of people around the world went to watch it is b/c people just wanted to see a damn HP movie it had been such a long time. It had almost been a year and a little more than 8 months. It looked so good on the previews but it was a damn mess on screen. It was all Yates-Goldenburg’s fault… they just don’t know how to make hp movies the way they should be, plain and simple. The script and the editing sucked and the music was worse. I mean what the hell do you call that? The music sounded stupid and childish and it didn’t fit with any of the emotion of the scenes. The Composer who made the score for the 1st, 2nd, and especially the 3rd should most definetly come back( I think his name was John Williams). The music was awesome in the third movie it fit with all of the emotion… HBP and DH are the saddest of the hp books they deserve to have the amount of emotional impact they did in the books as well as on screen. Guys, we should start some petition, survey or something to make it so the final HP movie is the best b/c this is all we have left and i want to walk out that movie crying because it was touching not b/c it sucked!!!! PLEASE!!!!!!!
Please let this be true! And that’s all I have to say about this matter.
I like Yates and his stile. It would be great to have him back, they all would have much more time together and this will be good for 6 and 7.
I really hope to have an 4 hours DH (and an extended version to five hours of all seven movies)
I dont think that OOTP was a bad movie in fact i think it was the best but yet again im one of those people who think the movies just keep getting better and better and the more i watch OOTP the more i love it. of course when i first saw the movie i thought it went really fast then i saw it again and loved it even more (as i said earlier) and ive heard some of the things that there doing with Quiditch in the sixth movie and im thrilled with what is coming and if David Yates does the last movie i think it will be exelent!!! i like the countdown idea!!
no E.K. your not alone on that I completely agree that they get better with every installment- me and many others on this site have tried to explain to the “OOTP is the worst movie” haters that , that book took alot of twists and turns in the plot they had no choice but to slim it down to just the crucial info, that was needed. Yes Dobby and the locket could’ve been added but Jo looks at that and all the scripts as we know so if she didnt approve then she would’ve said. And as my idol Alan Rickman said very nobaly ” making a movie is not about just one person but it invloves a HUGE team of people” so therefore I dont think there is one person to blame for things we dont like about the movies.
NO! Please no…I love David really…but…AHH…The Giver is SOOO much better suited to him, THATS what he should be doing…come on! He would make the giver brilliant!
huh?NO! i thought it will be spielberg… haistt!!!huhuhu or maybe tim burton will be better,
NO NO NO NO!! I wanted Alfonso Cuaron to direct the seventh movie. Azkaban was by far the best film of the series (I’ll admit they changed the characters a little two much…Ron and Hermione, anybody? ) but still, he did such a marvelous job. And he really got good performances out of the trio.
omg r u people deluded, the fifth film was the worst one of the bunch, it didnt connect with the audience and people who didnt read the book found it hard to follow!!!! PLEASE DO NOT BRING BACK YATES!!! besides his already done it twice(2nd time im hoping not as a bad as the first, i mean Ron had no lines!!! and i loves HBP). i vote for peter jackson or alfonso cuaron and the film should totally be 4 hours long, i’d sit through and watch it!!!!
NO2YATES- even if ron didn’t have a ton of lines, they were the most cannon lines yet.
I wish they would have the writer from OoTP come back. he put so many lines from the books in.
deathly hallows should not be split. IM WITH THE PERSON THAT SAYD A FOUR HOUR HARRY POTTER FILM WOULD BE A TREAT!!! that would be awesome…
@NO2YATES- just because we dont agree with you that OOTP was the worst doesnt mean we are delusional. We just like to look at this realistically- kind of like the new cast members who also get butchered every time we hear of a new one. I think based on what I know of how the world works we all need to remember ,including myself that we all percieve these films differently and we never have say so- besides if you are a true HP fan you will love the movie anyway. I have never seen any changes to the movies that have totally ruined the book to the point where they should be condemed all bad.
zomg there gonna make THE GIVER into a movie?
? David Yates would awesome at directing that Dan would be a sweeeeeeet Jonas… but i guess, if he likes HP so much, maybe…idk really long as Kreacher and Dobby are back and they call Tonks Dora…lol =)